Beyond Dual Power: Prefiguration and the Appropriation of Space
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
In the wake of ‘assembly movements’ such as Occupy Wall Street, the concept of ‘prefiguration’ has received increased attention in radical political theory. What remains undertheorised, however, is the manner and the extent to which prefiguration often implies a territorial claim as a way to secede from existing power relations and institutions. This article seeks to establish this relation between prefiguration and the appropriation of space. It first retraces the idea of prefiguration as a revolutionary strategy to the Paris Commune of 1871 and reconstructs how this experience led to a split within the international workers’ movement. It then continues to distinguish between prefiguration and ‘dual power’, which was introduced by Lenin, and argues that the latter does not bear the same territorial connotation. Finally, the paper turns to a contemporary example of prefigurative politics that is underpinned by a territorial claim – namely, the ZAD or zone à défendre in Notre-Dame-des-Landes.
Downloads
Article Details
References
Anonymous (2012). Notre-Dame-des-Landes : Allez dire à Rome que son empire s’arrête ici ! Le club de Mediapart, 7 Novembre 2012. [Available at: https://blogs.mediapart.fr/bob92 zinn/blog/071112/notre-dame-des-landes-allez-dire-rome-que-son-empire-sarrete-ici]
Anonymous (2015). De la ZAD aux Communaux ? Quelques pistes à explorer pour aller plus loin. zad.nadir.org, 17 June 2015. [Available at: https://zad.nadir.org/spip.php?article3067]
Audin, Michèle (2021). La semaine sanglante. Mai 1871. Légendes et comptes. Paris: Libertalia.
Baker, Adam J. (2012). Already Occupied: Indigenous Peoples, Set-tler Colonialism and Occupy Movements in North America. Social Movement Studies, 11(3-4), 327-334.
Baker, Mike (2020). Free Food, Free Speech and Free of Police: Inside Seattle’s ‘Autonomous Zone.’ New York Times, 11 June 2020. [Availa-ble at: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/11/us/seattle autonomous-zone.html]
Baker, Zoe (2023). Means and Ends: The Revolutionary Practice of Anarchism in Europe and the United States. Chico and Edin-burgh: AK Press.
Bakunin, Michael (1974). Selected Writings. Edited and introduced by Arthur Lehning. New York: Grove Press.
Bakunin, Michael (1990). Statism and Anarchy. Translated by Marshall Schatz. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Bevins, Vincent (2023). If We Burn: The Mass Protest Decade and the Missing Revolution. London: Wildfire.
Bey, Hakim (2003). T.A.Z. The Temporary Autonomous Zone, Onto-logical Anarchy, Poetic Terrorism. Brooklyn: Autonomedia.
Biehl, Janet and Bookchin, Murray (1998). The Politics of Social Ecology: Libertarian Municipalism. Montreal: Black Rose Books.
Blumenfeld, Jacob (2023). Expropriation of the Expropriators. Philosophy and Social Criticism, 49(4), 431-447.
Boggs, Carl (1977). Marxism, Prefigurative Communism, and the Problem of Workers’ Control. Radical America, 11(6), 99-122.
Bookchin, Murray (1995). From Urbanization to Cities: Towards a New Politics of Citizenship. London: Cassell.
Bookchin, Murray (2005). The Ecology of Freedom. The Emer-gence and Dissolution of Hierarchy. Edinburgh and Oakland: AK Press.
Bookchin, Murray (2015). The Next Revolution: Popular Assem-blies and the Promise of Direct Democracy. Edited by Debbie Bookchin and Blair Taylor. London: Verso.
Bouchain, Patrick et al (2018). Comme à la ZAD de Notre-Dame-des-Landes, défendons d’autres manières d’habiter. Le club de Mediapart, 6 Avril 2018. [Available at: https://blogs.mediapart.fr/les-invites-de-mediapart/blog/060418/comme-la-zad-de-notre-dame-des-landes-defendons-dautres-manieres-d-habiter]
Bray, Mark (2013). Translating Anarchy: the Anarchism of Occupy Wall Street. Winchester and Washington: Zero Books.
Butler, Judith (2015). Notes Toward a Performative Theory of As-sembly. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Castells, Manuel (1983). The City and the Grassroots: A Cross-Cultural Theory of Urban Social Movements. London: Edward Arnold.
Chuzeville, Julien (2021). Léo Frankel: Communard sans fron-tières. Paris: Libertalia.
Cole, Peter, Struthers, David and Zimmer, Kenyon (2017). Intro-duction. In Cole, Peter, Struthers, David and Zimmer, Kenyon (eds.). Wobblies of the World: A Global History of the IWW (1-25). London: Pluto Press.
Collectif Comm’un (2019). Habiter en lutte : Quarante ans de ré-sistance. Paris: Le passager clandestin.
Cornell, Andy (2016). Unruly Equality: U.S. Anarchism in the 20th Century. Oakland: University of California Press.
Crass, Chris. (2013). Towards Collective Liberation: Anti-racist Organizing, Feminist Praxis, and Movement Building Strategy. Oakland: PM Press.
Crimethinc (2018). La ZAD: Another End of the World is Possible. Crimethinc.com, 9 April 2018. [Available at: https://nl.crimethinc.com/2018/04/09/la-zad-another-end-of-the-world-is-possible-learning-from-50-years-of-struggle-at-notre-dame-des-landes]
Damier, Vadim (2009). Anarcho-Syndicalism in the 20th Century. Translated by Malcolm Archibald. Edmonton: Black Cat Press.
Debord, Guy, Kotányi, Attila and Vaneigem, Raoul (2006 [1962]). Theses on the Paris Commune. In Knabb, Ken (ed.). Situationist International Anthology (398-402). Berkely: Bureau of Public Secrets.
Deluermoz, Quentin (2021). Commune(s) 1870-1871. Une traver-sée des mondes au XIXe siècle. Paris: Seuil.
Dixon, Chris (2014). Another Politics: Talking Across Today’s Transformative Movements. Oakland: University of California Press.
Douzinas, Costas (2013). Philosophy and Resistance in the Crisis: Greece and the Future of Europe. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Dupeyron, Jean-François (2020). À l’école de la Commune de Pa-ris. L’histoire d’une autre école. Dijon: Raisons et Passions.
Eckhardt, Wolfgang (2016). The First Socialist Schism: Bakunin vs. Marx in the International Working Men’s Association. Translated by Robert M. Homsi, Jesse Cohn, Cian Lawless, Nestor McNab, and Bas Moreel. Oakland: PM Press.
Eichner, Carolyn (2004). Surmounting the Barricades: Women in the Paris Commune. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
Eichner, Carolyn (2022). The Paris Commune: A Brief Introduc-tion. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.
Elden, Stuart (2013). The Birth of Territory. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Engels, Friedrich (1987). Anti-Dühring. In Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels Collected Works vol. 25. New York: International Pub-lishers.
Ervin, Lorenzo Kom’Boa (2021). Anarchism and the Black Revolu-tion, revised edition. London: Pluto Press.
Flesher-Fominaya, Cristina (2020). Democracy Reloaded: Inside Spain’s Political Laboratory from 15-M to Podemos. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Franks, Benjamin (2003). The Direct Action Ethic from 59 Up-wards. Anarchist Studies 11(1), 13-41.
Fremeaux, Isabelle and Jordan, Jay (2021). We Are ‘Nature’ De-fending Itself. Entangling Art, Activism and Autonomous Zones. London: Pluto Press.
Gordon, Uri (2008). Anarchy Alive! Anti-Authoritarian Politics from Practice to Theory. London: Pluto Press.
Gordon, Uri (2018). Prefigurative Politics between Ethical Practice and Absent Promise. Political Studies, 66(2), 521-537.
Gottmann, Jean (1973). The Significance of Territory. Char-lottesville: The University Press of Virginia.
Gould, Roger V. (1995). Insurgent Identities: Class, Community and Protest in Paris from 1848 to the Commune. Chicago: Uni-versity of Chicago Press.
Graeber, David (2013). The Democracy Project: a History, a Crisis, a Movement. London: Allen Lane.
Greenberg, Louis M. (1971). Sisters of Liberty: Marseille, Lyon, Paris and the Reaction to a Centralized State, 1868-1871. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.
Guin, Yannick (1969). La commune de Nantes. Paris: François Maspero.
Halvorsen, Sam (2015). Encountering Occupy London: Boundary Making and the Territoriality of Urban Activism. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, 33, 314-330.
Hardt, Michael (2023). The Subversive Seventies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hardt, Michael and Negri, Antonio (2009). Commonwealth. Cam-bridge: Belknap/Harvard University Press.
Ince, Anthony (2012). In the Shell of the Old: Anarchist Geogra-phies of Territorialisation. Antipode, 44(5), 1645-1666.
Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) (2022). Constitution of the Industrial Workers of the World. [Available at: https://www.iww.org/resources/constitution/]
Johnson, Martin Philip (1996). The Paradise of Association. Politi-cal Culture and Popular Organizations in the Paris Commune of 1871. Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press.
Jura Federation (2015). Sonvillier Circular. In Graham, Robert (ed.). Anarchism: A Documentary History of Libertarian Ideas. Volume I: From Anarchy to Anarchism (300CE to 1939) (96-98). Montreal: Black Rose Books.
Kinna, Ruth (2019). The Government of No One: The Theory and Practice of Anarchism. London: Pelican Books.
Kinna, Ruth, Prichard, Alex, Swann, Thomas and Seeds for Change (2023). Anarchic Agreements. A Field Guide to Building Groups and Coalitions. Oakland: PM Press.
Lakey, George (1987). Powerful Peacemaking: A Strategy for a Living Revolution. Philadelphia: New Society Publishers.
Lefebvre, Henri (2018). La Proclamation de la Commune : 26 Mars 1871. Paris: La Fabrique.
Lefrançais, Gustave (2018). Étude sur le mouvement communa-liste. Paris: Klincksieck.
Lenin, Vladimir Illjitsj (1964a). The Dual Power. Collected Works 24, (38-41). Moscow: Progress Publishers.
Lenin, Vladimir Illjitsj. (1964b). The Tasks of the Proletariat in Our Revolution. Collected Works 24 (55-91). Moscow: Progress Publishers.
Lenin, Vladimir Illjitsj (1964c). Has Dual Power Disappeared? Col-lected Works 24 (445-448). Moscow: Progress Publishers.
Lenin, Vladimir Illjitsj (1987). The State and Revolution. In Christman, Henry M. (ed.). Essential Works of Lenin (271-364). New York: Dover.
Lissagaray, Prosper-Olivier (2012). The History of the Paris Com-mune of 1871. London: Verso.
Lorey, Isabell (2020). Demokratie im Präsens: Eine Theorie der politischen Gegenwart. Berlin: Suhrkamp Verlag.
Marx, Karl (2010a). Manifesto of the Communist Party. In The Revolutions of 1848: Political Writings Volume 1 (62-98). Lon-don: Verso.
Marx, Karl (2010b). The Civil War in France: Address of the Gen-eral Council. In The First International and After: Political Writings Volume 3 (187-235). London: Verso.
Marx, Karl (2010c). Critique of the Gotha Programme. In The First International and After: Political Writings Volume 3 (339-359). London: Verso.
Mauvaise Troupe Collective (2018). The ZAD and NoTAV: Territo-rial Struggle and the Making of a New Political Intelligence. Translated by Kristin Ross. London: Verso.
Merriman, John (2014). Massacre. The Life and Death of the Paris Commune of 1871. Yale: Yale University Press.
Milstein, Cindy (2010). Anarchism and its Aspirations. Oakland and Edinburgh: AK Press.
Mintz, Frank (2013). Anarchism and Workers’ Self-Management in Revolutionary Spain. Translated by Paul Sharkey. Oakland, CA and Edinburgh: AK Press.
Monticelli, Lara (2021). On the Necessity of Prefigurative Politics. Thesis Eleven, 167 (1), 99-118.
Muldoon, James, Müller, Mirjam and Leipold, Bruno (2023). ‘Aux Ouvrières!’: Socialist Feminism in the Paris Commune. Intel-lectual History Review, 33(2), 331-351.
Musto, Marcello (2018). Another Marx: Early Manuscripts to the International. London: Bloomsbury Academic.
Nicholls, Julia (2019). Revolutionary Thought after the Paris Commune, 1871-1885. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Pailloux, Anne-Laure (2015). Deferred Development Zone (ZAD) versus “Zone to be Protected”. Analysis of a Struggle for Au-tonomy in/of Rural Space. Justice Spatiale/Spatial Justice 7. [Available at: http://www.jssj.org/article/zone-damenagement-differe-contre-zone-a-defendre-analyse-dune-lutte-pour-lautonomie-dansde-lespace-rural/]
Pickerill, Jenny and Chatterton, Paul (2006). Notes Toward Auton-omous Geographies: Creation, Resistance, and Self-Management as Survival Tactics. Progress in Human Geogra-phy, 30(6), 730-746.
Pickerill, Jenny and Krinsky, John (2012). Why Does Occupy Mat-ter? Social Movement Studies, 11(3-4), 279-287.
Pouget, Émile (2010). L’action directe. In Chueca, Miguel (ed.). L’action directe et autres écrits syndicalistes (153-183). Mar-seilles: Agone.
Price, Wayne (2023). Conceptions of Dual Power and Prefigurative Politics. New Politics, XIX(2). [Available at: https://newpol.org/issue_post/conceptions-of-dual-power-and-prefigurative-politics/]
Pruvost, Genevière (2017). A Critique in Practice: Everyday Life in the ‘ZAD,’ Notre-Dame-des-Landes (2013-2024). Politix, 117(1), 35-62.
Raekstad, Paul and Gradin, Sofa Sajo (2020). Prefigurative Poli-tics: Building Tomorrow Today. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Rocker, Rudolf (2004). Anarcho-Syndicalism: Theory and Prac-tice. Oakland, CA and Edinburgh: AK Press.
Ross, Kristin (2008). The Emergence of Social Space: Rimbaud and the Paris Commune. London: Verso.
Ross, Kristin (2015). Communal Luxury: The Political Imaginary of the Paris Commune. London: Verso.
Ross, Kirstin (2018). Preface: Making a Territory. In Mauvaise Troupe Collective, The ZAD and NoTAV: Territorial Struggle and the Making of a New Political Intelligence. Translated by Kristin Ross, (ix-xxiii). London: Verso.
Ross, Kristin (2023). The Politics and Poetics of Everyday Life. London: Verso.
Ross, Kristin (2024). The Commune Form. The Transformation of Everyday Life. London: Verso.
Rougerie, Jacques (2004). Paris Libre 1871. Paris: Éditions du seuil.
Schmidt, Michael and van der Walt, Lucien (2009). Black Flame: The Revolutionary Class Poli-tics of Anarchism and Syndical-ism. Oakland and Edinburgh: AK Press.
Schulkind, Euegene (ed.) (1972). The Paris Commune of 1871: The View from the Left. London: Jonathan Cape.
Shafer, David A. (2005). The Paris Commune. French Politics, Cul-ture and Society at the Crossroads of the Revolutionary Tradi-tion and Revolutionary Socialism. London and New York: Pal-grave-Macmillan.
Sitrin, Marina and Azzellini, Dario (2014). They Can’t Represent Us! Reinventing Democracy From Greece to Occupy. London: Verso.
Smit, Peter-Ben (2024). Prefiguration of the Nation: The Soteriolo-gy and Ecclesiology of the Iglesia Filipina Independiente in the Early 20th Century. Exchange, 53, 23-45.
The Invisible Committee (2009). The Coming Insurrection. Trans-lated by Robert Hurley. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
The Invisible Committee (2015). To Our Friends. Translated by Robert Hurley. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
The Invisible Committee (2017). Now. Translated by Robert Hur-ley. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
Thompson, AK (2017). Occupation, Decolonisation and Reciprocal Violence, or History Responds to Occupy’s Anti-Colonial Crit-ics. In Brown, Gavin, Feigenbaum, Anna, Frenzel, Fabian and MdCurdy, Patrick. Protest Camps in International Context: Spaces, Infrastructures, and Media of Resistance (179-198). Policy Press.
Tomba, Massimiliano (2019). Insurgent Universality: An Alterna-tive Legacy of Modernity. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Tombs, Robert (2013). The Paris Commune 1871. London: Routledge.
Trotsky, Leon (2017). History of the Russian Revolution. Translat-ed by Max Eastman. London: Penguin.
Tufekçi, Zeynep (2017). Twitter and Tear Gas: The Power and Fragility of Networked Protest. New Haven: Yale University Press.
van de Sande, Mathijs (2013). The Prefigurative Politics of Tahrir Square –An Alternative Perspective on the 2011 Revolutions. Res Publica, 19(3), 223-239.
van de Sande, Mathijs (2023). Prefigurative Democracy: Protest, Social Movements, and the Political Institution of Society. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Verdier, Margot (2021). Le commun de l’autonomie. Une sociolo-gie anarchiste de la zad de Notre-Dame-des-Landes. Vulaines sur Seines: Croquant.
Yates, Luke (2015). Rethinking Prefiguration: Alternatives, Mi-cropolitics and Goals in Social Movements. Social Movement Studies, 14(1), 1-21.
Yates, Luke (2021). Prefigurative Politics and Social Movement Strategy: The Roles of Prefiguration in the Reproduction, Mo-bilisation and Coordination of Movements. Political Studies 69 (4), 1033-1052.
Zadforever (2018). The Revenge Against the Commons. In Squat-ting Everywhere Collective (eds.). Fighting for Spaces, Fighting for Our Lives: Squatting Movements Today, (118-145). Müntster: Assemblage.
Zadist (2014). In the Grove, and Elsewhere, Resistance and Sabotage. zad.nadir.org, 25 february 2014. [Available at: https://zad.nadir.org/spip.php?article2234]
Zaidman, Pierre-Henri (2008). Le mandat impératif. De la Révolu-tion française à la Commune de Paris. Paris: Éditions du Monde Libertaire & Les éditions libertaires.
Zibechi, Raúl (2012). Territories in Resistance: A Cartography of Latin American Social Movements. Translated by Ramor Ryan. Edinburgh and Oakland: AK Press.